MLB · September 13, 2026

Marlins Upset Dodgers as Prediction Flawed by Bullpen Stability

The Miami Marlins defied the odds by edging out the Los Angeles Dodgers six to four, completing a surprising victory that turned the Tide at home. This outcome stands in stark contrast to the pre-game analysis, which had firmly backed the Dodgers as the superior team on paper. While the forecast correctly anticipated a tight contest given the high volatility of the matchup, it ultimately failed to account for the critical defensive errors that would allow Miami to capitalize on Los Angeles's struggles.

The pre-game case rested on the assumption that the Dodgers' offense, despite Shohei Ohtani being sidelined with biceps inflammation, would still overpower Miami through sheer depth. Analysts noted the potential risk of Dodgers starter Emmet Sheehan’s command issues but believed his superior strikeout metrics and the Marlins' low-scoring environment would keep the game manageable. The prediction argued that Miami’s reliance on young talent like Eury Perez was a vulnerability that Los Angeles’s experienced lineup could exploit early and often.

What the forecast missed was the Marlins' bullpen resilience and a defensive lapse by Los Angeles in the ninth inning. Despite Tanner Scott blowing the save after inheriting a lead, Miami’s closer Dax Fulton managed to secure the final outs, preserving the win. Meanwhile, the Dodgers’ offense remained stifled by Miami’s pitching, with rookie Josue De Paula shouldering the offensive load. The game’s decisive moments came when Miami turned a crucial double play and capitalized on a Dodgers error, proving that defensive execution often outweighs statistical projections in high-leverage innings.

In hindsight, the prediction was wrong because it overvalued individual pitching metrics while underweighting team defensive cohesion. The Marlins’ ability to protect a narrow lead and execute in the clutch proved more valuable than the Dodgers' offensive firepower. This upset serves as a reminder that in baseball, volatile pitching performances and defensive errors can quickly dismantle even the most statistically sound forecasts, leaving the underdog to reign supreme.

On the field

Edgardo Henriquez struggled, allowing three hits in a performance well above his 0.6 average. Tanner Scott also faltered, giving up three hits against his 0.7 norm. On the mound, Griffin Conine dominated with three strikeouts, surpassing his 1 average. Emmet Sheehan was a bright spot, limiting the opposition to two hits, down from his 4.5 average. The Marlins’ victory was sealed in the ninth inning, where they erupted for four runs, the game’s biggest scoring burst, to overcome the Dodgers and secure the 6-4 win.

Highlights

← All analysis

Images and videos courtesy ESPN