MLB · September 12, 2026

Blue Jays crush Orioles as Bradish’s slump deepens

Toronto dismantled Baltimore with a decisive seven-to-three victory, rendering the pre-game forecast for an upset completely incorrect. While the analytical case had constructed a narrow path for the Orioles to steal this one, relying on a perfect storm of pitching excellence and bullpen endurance, the reality on the field told a story of rapid regression and offensive dominance. The forecast, which positioned the Blue Jays as slight underdogs despite home-field advantage, failed to account for the severity of the unraveling on the mound for Baltimore, allowing Toronto to seize control early and never look back.

The pre-game narrative hinged entirely on Kyle Bradish overcoming recent walk issues and pitching deep into the game to bypass Toronto’s lineup. Analysts had flagged Bradish as luck-dependent, noting that his actual earned run average was misleadingly better than his underlying performance metrics suggested. This distinction proved to be the fatal flaw in the Orioles’ plan. Rather than overcoming his struggles, Bradish saw his poor underlying indicators materialize into tangible damage, surrendering five runs on eight hits in merely three innings and effectively handing the game to Toronto before the middle of the fifth.

Conversely, the forecast correctly identified Spencer Miles as the pivotal factor, citing his elite underlying performance. Miles delivered exactly that expected excellence, pitching two scoreless innings and striking out five batters while allowing only a single hit. His dominant opener set the tone for the Blue Jays’ offense, capitalizing on the early advantage to put the game out of reach. The prediction missed on the upset scenario by underestimating how quickly Bradish’s statistical bad luck would turn into actual losses, confirming that the momentum was firmly with Toronto from the first pitch.

Game clips

Vladimir Guerrero Jr. hits an RBI double
Brett Bateman crushes a home run
Alejandro Kirk smashes a home run
Pete Alonso crushes a home run
← All analysis

Images and videos courtesy ESPN